The Lawyer Skills AI Can’t Replace: Building Judgment and Client Trust in the AI Era

By Loretta Kilday

An AI-generated memo can give you a starting point. It can also steer your thinking before you have decided what the client needs. The challenge is to use the assistance while preserving the habits that make your advice useful: identifying missing facts, questioning an attractive argument and explaining why a legally available option may be a poor choice for this client. Let’s review a few lawyer skills AI can’t replace and how to protect them while using AI tools responsibly.

Shrugging person with an old TV showing “AI” for a head, surrounded by question marks, illustrating lawyer skills AI can’t replace

Here’s advice on how you can practice those skills and reinforce good habits during ordinary client work — before you enter a prompt.

Consider two hypothetical clients seeking advice about business ownership disputes.

One client owns part of a family manufacturing company. Reliable income and preserving family relationships matter more than a quick exit.

The other client wants to leave a startup and begin a new venture as soon as possible.

Both may need advice about a buyout. Their priorities could lead to different recommendations, even where the available legal options overlap. Their agreements, business structures and governing law may differ too.

Before researching, ask what a workable result would look like six months from now. Find out what the client can afford to spend and which consequences they most want to avoid. Check your understanding with them rather than assuming you have identified their priorities.

Keep the allocation of authority clear. Under ABA Model Rule 1.2, clients decide the objectives of representation and whether to settle; lawyers consult with them about the means. Check the corresponding rules in your jurisdiction.

Your recommendation should connect the legal options to the client’s informed choices.

Before opening an AI tool, write a short assessment of the matter. Identify the likely issue, the missing fact most likely to change your advice and the strongest argument against your initial position.

This gives you something to compare with AI output. Otherwise, a polished response from AI can become the framework for your thinking simply because you read it first.

Where AI Comes In

AI may help identify an overlooked issue or competing argument. Treat those suggestions as leads to investigate.

A study published in the Journal of Empirical Legal Studies in 2025 reported hallucination rates of 17% to 33% across the three commercial legal research tools tested. Those findings concern the versions and benchmark questions studied at the time, and do not establish the performance of today’s products.

When reviewing research, check whether the authority exists, remains applicable and supports the proposition being made. Read enough of the underlying source to understand its limits. A real citation can still support the wrong argument.

Client Communication Skills: Ask Follow-Up Questions Instead of Guessing

Clear language matters, but a plain-English explanation is useful only if it addresses the client’s actual concern. A client asking, “How long will this take?” might be worried about legal fees, disruption at work or the strain on a family relationship. Ask what makes the timing important. 

The same principle applies when financial strain affects a client’s legal decisions. AI can help organize relevant information, but a lawyer can help the client understand available debt relief options in light of their circumstances and the potential consequences of each choice.

Useful follow-up questions include:

  • What would make this option difficult for you?
  • Is there a deadline or commitment we have not discussed?
  • What concerns you most about the recommendation?

Avoid treating eye contact, silence or tone as reliable evidence of someone’s thoughts. Communication styles vary. Check your interpretation directly.

Before ending the meeting, summarize the next decision and explain the uncertainty that could affect it. Invite the client to correct your understanding. A brief written follow-up can record the agreed next step and who is responsible for it.

Negotiation Skills: Prepare, Then Revise Your Assumptions

Negotiation requires preparation and a willingness to discover that your initial reading was wrong.

An aggressive demand might reflect a bargaining tactic. It might also reflect a genuine financial constraint or instructions the other lawyer cannot change. Experience can help you form a hypothesis; questions and evidence help you test it.

Before a negotiation:

  1. Confirm the client’s priorities and your negotiating authority.
  2. Identify the alternatives if no agreement is reached.
  3. Separate essential terms from terms the client could trade.
  4. Explore nonfinancial options, such as timing or transition arrangements.
  5. Decide what information can be shared and what must remain protected.

Where AI Comes In

AI can help you rehearse responses using a hypothetical scenario that contains no client information. During the discussion, pay attention to what changes. A proposal you expected to fail may reveal an option worth exploring.

If an offer falls outside your authority, return to the client.

Make Using Tools Responsibly Part of the Work

For U.S. practitioners, ABA Formal Opinion 512 provides guidance on applying existing professional duties to generative AI. Applicable jurisdictional rules and court requirements govern your practice.

Before using client information, assess the tool’s retention, access and training practices. Obtain informed consent when required, including for the self-learning uses described in the opinion. General consent language in an engagement letter may be insufficient.

Confidentiality extends beyond privileged communications. Model Rule 1.6 covers information relating to a representation and requires reasonable efforts to prevent unauthorized disclosure or access. Removing a client’s name may leave identifying details.

Under Opinion 512, AI disclosure depends on the circumstances, including client requests and engagement terms. For hourly work, bill actual time spent, including appropriate review, rather than hours the technology saved. Other fee arrangements remain subject to Rule 1.5’s reasonableness requirements.

If you cannot evaluate a tool’s risks, resolve that uncertainty before using it for sensitive work.

Build Client Trust Through Follow-Through

Give clients a clear account of what you recommend and why. Explain what remains uncertain without promising an outcome you cannot control.

Practical follow-through helps. Record commitments, send updates when expected and tell clients promptly when the plan needs to change. If technology is part of their concern, explain how you use it and how you review its work.

After a matter closes or reaches a significant milestone, review one consequential decision with a colleague. Which assumption held up? What did the client tell you that changed your approach? Did the research miss something important?

Choose one lesson to carry into the next matter. On your next client call, leave enough time to ask a follow-up question and hear the full answer.

Image © iStockPhoto.com.

Sign up for Attorney at Work’s daily practice tips newsletter here and subscribe to our podcast, Attorney at Work Today.

share TWEET PIN IT share share
Loretta Kilday

Loretta Kilday has over 36 years of litigation and transactional experience, specializing in business, collection and family law. She frequently writes on various financial and legal matters. She is a graduate of DePaul University with a Juris Doctor degree and a spokesperson for the Debt Consolidation Care (DebtCC) online debt relief forum.

More Posts By This Author
MUST READ Articles for Law Firms Click to expand
envelope

Welcome to Attorney at Work!

       

Sign up for our free newsletter.

x

All fields are required. By signing up, you are opting in to Attorney at Work's free practice tips newsletter and occasional emails with news and offers. By using this service, you indicate that you agree to our Terms and Conditions and have read and understand our Privacy Policy.