Future of Law

Legal MSO Earnouts: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly

By Frederick Shelton and Ayven Dodd

There are some truly ugly MSO deals being done right now. Some private equity investors have figured out a rather ingenious way to buy law firms using the founders’ own money. Even worse, they can make the founders work another three years to earn the purchase price and then not pay them in full. The mechanism they’re using is called an earnout. While there are perfectly legitimate ways to structure one, some of the arrangements we’re seeing range from ugly to downright hideous. Here’s what you need to know about legal MSO earnouts before you sign any deal.

calcualtor with warning sign for legal MSO earnouts

(Ed. Note: For more background on MSOs, read “Private Equity Comes Knocking: The New Frontier of Law Firm Ownership” by Roy Ginsburg and “Mea Culpa: What I Got Wrong About Private Equity in Law Firms” by Brooke Lively.)

Based on our research and feedback from industry professionals, an estimated 20% to 25% of earnouts in the accounting industry were never paid. Imagine being told you’re going to get $40M for your law firm and only receiving $25M. That has happened.

The Ugly: EBITDA-Based Earnouts

Let’s take a law firm where the MSO negotiates a $4 million annual compensation scrape, meaning the founders agree to reduce their annual compensation by that amount, in order to make the firm’s value go up. Presto! The firm’s adjusted EBITDA is now $6 million. At an 8x multiple, we’ve got a $48 million valuation.

So far, nothing is necessarily wrong. Compensation scrapes are common in these transactions. But now comes the ugly part.

The investor offers $48 million, except $24 million is contingent on the firm achieving growth in profitability, for example, EBITDA hurdles every year for the next three years.

Think about that. The founders have already agreed to surrender $4 million in compensation over those three years. That means $12 million, or half of the remaining $24 million they’re going to be paid, is their own money! And if they don’t take future profits to levels defined by the MSO, they don’t get the $24 million — including the $12 million that they would have collected as income if they never did a deal!

The worst part? The investor may control the expenses that determine EBITDA.

Want to hire a new CFO at $400,000 annually? Go ahead. Spend $2 million on AI technology? Wonderful. Allocate another million in corporate overhead to the firm? Why not? Especially if it means screwing the partners out of their earnouts!

Congratulations! You’ve sold your law firm, taken a pay cut, acquired a new boss, and now have three years to earn the money you thought you were getting when you sold it.

That is ugly.

The Bad: Revenue-Based Earnouts

Revenue-based earnouts are somewhat less offensive because revenue is harder to manipulate through expenses. An MSO can’t reduce revenue simply by purchasing expensive software or hiring another executive.

But let’s not confuse less offensive with good.

Suppose your firm generates $30 million in annual revenue. The investor agrees to a purchase price that includes $10 million contingent on reaching $36 million in revenue within three years.

In those three years, your firm goes through an economic down cycle but bounces back and is generating $34 million. That’s more than 13% growth, which most business owners would consider pretty respectable.

Unfortunately, depending on the terms of your agreement, you may have just forfeited $10 million.

Why? Because you failed to achieve the investor’s projections.

And while revenue is less susceptible to manipulation than EBITDA, the investor may still control marketing budgets, staffing, expansion initiatives, and other decisions that influence your ability to grow.

The fundamental problem remains: Why should founders have to grow the business just to collect the purchase price for the business they’ve already built?

Revenue-based earnouts are a more attractive pair of handcuffs. But they’re still handcuffs.

So beware of any money that has to be earned.

The Good: Earnouts That Increase the Purchase Price

Now let’s talk about earnouts that make sense.

Suppose an investor agrees that your law firm is worth $50 million. That’s the negotiated value of the existing business, with the agreed base consideration not dependent on hitting future operating targets.

But the investor also recognizes that you and your partners have ambitious growth plans. So they offer another $10 million if the firm substantially exceeds mutually agreed performance targets over the next three years.

If the firm performs as expected or even hits a couple of bumps in the road, you still receive the full agreed base consideration. If the firm performs exceptionally well, you receive even more.

Now that is an earnout I can get behind!

The investor benefits from exceptional growth, and the founders share in the additional value they’ve created. Nobody has to worry about losing part of the original purchase price because someone at corporate headquarters decided the firm needed a new executive, a fancy AI platform, or a corporate retreat in Aspen.

Of course, the agreement still needs clearly defined performance metrics, accounting methodologies, and protections against financial manipulation. But the fundamental economic arrangement makes sense.

Good legal MSO earnouts reward extraordinary performance. Bad earnouts penalize founders for missing future projections set by others. Ugly earnouts make founders finance their own acquisitions.

The Purchase Price Is NOT the Purchase Price

One of the most important things we explain to law firm founders is that a $60 million offer is not necessarily worth more than a $50 million offer.

If the $60 million offer includes $20 million contingent on future performance, while the $50 million offer provides substantially greater certainty, which is actually the better deal?

That depends on the amount of cash at closing, the value and risk of rollover equity, the probability of receiving deferred consideration, and a host of other factors. But one thing is certain:

A dollar you might receive three years from now is not worth the same as a dollar you receive at closing.

After spending decades building a successful law firm, founders shouldn’t have to spend another three years financing its acquisition. Private equity investors have every right to negotiate the best deal they can. The founders sitting across the table need to understand the difference between a good deal, a bad deal and an ugly one.

The best Legal MSO transactions pay founders for the businesses they’ve already built and reward them for the additional value they create.

Frederick Shelton is the CEO of Shelton & Steele, which advocates for attorneys and law firms on M&A and legal MSOs. Fred can be reached at fs@sheltonsteele.com. Ayven Dodd is the President of Shelton & Steele, and he can be reached at ad@sheltonsteele.com.


“The Private Equity Buzz: Will MSOs Gain Traction in Small and Midsize Firms?” Roy S. Ginsburg breaks down the state of PE investment in law firms, who benefits from the MSO model, and what it means for small firm owners and retiring partners.

In “Partner Psychology: Expert Strategies for Negotiating Legal MSO Deals,” Frederick Shelton and Ayven Dodd explain why preparation and mindset are just as important as spotless financials, if not more so.

In “The Seven Pillars of MSO Deals,” the two dig into the fundamentals that law firm owners must understand if they expect to get the best terms. (Listen to the article below on Attorney at Work Today.)

Image © iStockPhoto.com.

Sign up for Attorney at Work’s daily practice tips newsletter here and subscribe to our podcast, Attorney at Work Today.

share TWEET PIN IT share share
Frederick Shelton and Ayven Dodd

Frederick Shelton is the CEO of national consultancy Shelton & Steele, where he advocates and advises attorneys and law firms on M&A and Legal MSOs. He can be reached at fs@sheltonsteele.com. Ayven Dodd is the President of Shelton & Steele. He recruits partners and groups for law firms, as well as advising them on MSOs. He can be reached at ad@sheltonsteele.com. Follow Shelton & Steele on LinkedIn.

More Posts By This Author
MUST READ Articles for Law Firms Click to expand
envelope

Welcome to Attorney at Work!

       

Sign up for our free newsletter.

x

All fields are required. By signing up, you are opting in to Attorney at Work's free practice tips newsletter and occasional emails with news and offers. By using this service, you indicate that you agree to our Terms and Conditions and have read and understand our Privacy Policy.