Get to the Point

Stop Using Squishy Language

By Theda C. Snyder

“One of the only”: the ambiguous phrase that keeps popping up. I don’t know what this means — and neither do your readers.

A recent newspaper story about Martha Stewart’s sale of her brand quoted a branding maven: “When [Stewart] started, she really was one of the only people in this category in terms of experts that were really relevant.”

Let’s overlook the issue of whether Martha is a “who,” not a “that,” though some grammarians have recently blessed such a departure from traditional syntax. There’s also the question of whether, if she were “one,” she was (not were) relevant. (No, we are not dealing with the subjunctive here.) Or does the speaker mean it was the experts “that were really relevant”?

Why “One of the Only”?

At best, this sentence is confusing. Does the speaker mean Martha was the only one? Does she mean “one of the few”? “One of a handful”? If Martha and Suzy Homemaker were the only experts in the field of “do-it-yourself domestic makeovers,” Martha’s field per the article, that would be interesting. Maybe the speaker didn’t know off the top of her head who the experts were in 1991 — or even how many there were. We can cut the speaker some slack because she was responding to questions in an interview without time for revision. Also, her expertise is branding, not domestic makeovers.

The thing is, the same day I read this headline on a legal website: “South Carolina Is One of the Only States That Still Doesn’t Have a Hate Crime Law.” The article clarifies that five states lack such a law. So why did the headline writer choose this construction? Why not write “South Carolina Is One of Five States Without a Hate Crime Law”?

Lawyers are in the business of communicating ideas clearly. Googling “one of the only” brings up the comments of two sets of language warriors: those who say this idiomatic expression is perfectly fine and those who say it is meaningless if not offensive.

Are you willing to gamble your case or your client base on which camp your judges and clients fall in?

Be Precise

If you use this construction, please stop. Unlike the branding guru, you don’t get a pass on not knowing the details. Your job is to nail down the ambiguities before your fingers touch the keyboard. Your raison d’ ệtre is communication to or on behalf of your client without confusion and without raising eyebrows because of your phraseology.

“One of the only” covers up a knowledge gap with squishy, can’t-put-your-finger-on-it language. If you know the number, such as the number of states without a certain law, tell the reader. If you don’t know, and it’s important, find out. If it’s not important, don’t include it in your brief or client report.

In 1991, Martha Stewart was a pioneer in calling public attention to home-based skills. Does it matter to a discussion of her brand how many pioneers there were?

Catch up on past “Get to the Point” columns here.

Illustration ©ImageZoo.

Categories: Communications Skills, Daily Dispatch, Get to the Point, Legal Writing
Originally published September 8, 2015
Last updated April 26, 2018
share TWEET PIN IT share share
Teddy Snyder Theda C. Snyder

Theda “Teddy” Snyder mediates civil disputes, workers’ compensation and insurance coverage cases, including COVID-19 related coverage disputes, in person or by video. Teddy has practiced in a variety of settings and frequently speaks and writes about settlements and the business of law. She was a Fellow of the College of Law Practice Management and is the author of four ABA books, including “Women Rainmakers’ Best Marketing Tips, 4th Edition” as well as “Personal Injury Case Evaluation” available on Amazon.com. Based in Los Angeles, Teddy can be found at SnyderMediations.com and on Twitter @SnyderMediation.

More Posts By This Author
MUST READ Articles for Law Firms Click to expand
envelope

Welcome to Attorney at Work!

Sign up for our free newsletter.

x

All fields are required. By signing up, you are opting in to Attorney at Work's free practice tips newsletter and occasional emails with news and offers. By using this service, you indicate that you agree to our Terms and Conditions and have read and understand our Privacy Policy.