From Panic to Profits

Modernizing Law Firm Overhead: Finding Your True Profit Center

By Brooke Lively

Law firm overhead is more than the light bill and rent. It’s also the people with nonbillable time, like your office manager and sales team.

law firm overhead

Highlights

  • The Rule of Thirds Has Evolved: In a modern legal landscape, overhead includes the total cost of your nonbillable workforce once your firm passes key revenue milestones ($1M–$2M+).
  • Isolate Nonbillable Payroll for True ROI: Shifting administrative, intake, and dedicated marketing salaries into overhead reveals the exact profit margin of your actual billable producers.
  • Owner Salaries Must Reflect Operational Reality: As firm owners step back from casework to focus on visionary growth, their compensation must shift from a direct labor expense to an administrative overhead cost.

I talk to a lot of law firms about the “Rule of Thirds.” Basically, you divide your revenue into thirds for people, law firm overhead and profit.

  • One-third of revenue goes to pay the people doing the work
  • One-third of revenue goes to overhead
  • One-third of revenue goes to profit

But people often ask me, “What exactly is in law firm overhead?” For firm owners working to build a sustainable business model, mastering these categories is a fundamental step in managing a law firm effectively.

Breaking Down Law Firm Overhead Items

There are the easy elements in your overhead: rent, phone, copier rental, research subscriptions, case management software, marketing. All the things that you have to pay for each month, whether you use them or not, that keep the lights on and the doors open to your firm.

When your business is still small, overhead is everything except payroll, taxes and benefits.

But as you grow, the way you look at your people and overhead starts to morph. In today’s landscape, where remote and hybrid work environments are standard practice rather than an experimental trend, your operational structure changes fast. Once you pass the $1 million mark, and definitely as you hit $2 million, you start to move some salaries out of the people category and put them in overhead. This is because you are becoming a more professionally run business. These are the four you’ll move first.

The Big Four People Expenses to Move to Overhead

1. Marketing Salaries

As you begin to bring marketing in-house, it is time to start moving those salaries out of the people category and put them under “marketing,” a subset of overhead. These are full-time people whose only responsibilities are marketing. I’m not talking about the legal assistant or receptionist you task with doing social media. These are dedicated marketing individuals with 100% of their time (and therefore their salary) going to marketing. The reason you want to move marketing salaries under overhead is so you can know the true return on investment of all the money you spend on marketing, not just your pay-per-click, SEO and website expenses.

2. Administrative or Nonbillable People

When your firm starts, employees (you especially) wear numerous hats. The owner is generally doing attorney work, paralegal work, picking up the office manager duties, marketing and even bookkeeping. You hire a paralegal who answers the phones, does paralegal work, and makes sure you have printer paper. The larger your firm becomes, the more people are able to shed hats and start doing just a single job. Then you hire a receptionist who takes on the phones and office paper. And this goes on until you start to see a true divide between those people who are doing billable work and those who are supporting the operations of the office and don’t contribute at all to the legal work.

When a position becomes 100% nonbillable it is time to create a new section on your P&L under overhead called “administrative salaries.” Move all your nonbillable payroll expenses (office manager, receptionist, bookkeeper) out of the people category and into overhead.

3. Sales and Intake

Just like with your administrative team, in the beginning your paralegal is doing the filing, handling intake, answering the phone and doing billable work. Sales or intake is a great example of a job that is done by multiple people in smaller firms. The owner does the sales call, the receptionist sends out the fee agreement, and the paralegal or office manager gets the new client set up in the practice management system. When you bring on a dedicated salesperson, they need to move out of people and into the overhead category.

The biggest question is where should they sit in overhead? Do they go into that administrative bucket or are they a marketing cost? Those are both valid locations and I am going to give you the classic attorney answer of, “It depends.” Neither is right and neither is wrong. It is a matter of personal preference and of how you think about your firm. What is important, is that you move them out of your people category.

4. And Then There’s You

Your job also evolves as your firm grows. Gone are the days when you spend every night and weekend doing all the billable work you haven’t been able to get to during the week. Now you have associates and paralegals doing it and you have turned your talents to areas of the firm where you are most valuable: usually sales, marketing and planning strategic growth. In the book Traction: Get a Grip on Your Business, Gino Wickman calls these people “visionaries” because they are the ones who see the path forward and drive toward those goals.

As you shed billable work and take on more visionary projects, you also need to migrate your salary toward the administrative salary bucket in the overhead category.

Your Biggest Question About Law Firm Overhead? Growth Trajectory

When people ask me what is in law firm overhead, I have a base answer and then the “it depends” answer. The biggest question for you is this: Where are you on the growth trajectory? And is it time to acknowledge that not all people sit in the people part of the Rule of Thirds equation?


Law Firm Overhead FAQ

Historically, firms tried to stick to a rigid 30% to 35% ceiling, but in today’s environment, a healthy overhead range typically lands between 40% and 45% of gross revenue. For a firm bringing in $3M to $5M, that translates to roughly $1.2M to $2.2M in total overhead. Keep in mind, this number looks higher because well-managed firms now properly bundle nonbillable administrative salaries, advanced tech stacks, and specialized intake teams directly into their overhead data. If you are sitting below 35%, you may actually be under-investing in the infrastructure needed to scale.

Spreadsheets are a great place to capture history, but they are notoriously tough to use for real-time forecasting. The trick is to stop looking at your data as a static rearview mirror and start using it to run small, “safe-to-fail” operational experiments. Establish your baseline overhead metric this month, make one deliberate adjustment—like automating a piece of your intake pipeline—and watch how it impacts your bottom line over the next 90 days. Once you see the direct correlation between tracking adjustments and profit margins, your data stops being an administrative chore and becomes your primary strategic guide.

When your space is fixed, look immediately to your variable and hidden overhead drains—specifically, your technology stack and your administrative workflows. Many firms suffer from “software creep,” paying for duplicate features across multiple platforms. Streamlining your practice management software can yield immediate relief. Additionally, look at your billing workflows; reducing the time it takes to get an invoice out the door directly improves your cash flow, effectively mitigating the burden of that fixed rent check. For a deeper dive into optimizing these workflows, check out our guide on Law Firm Billing Leakage: You Are Giving Money Away Before the Invoice Goes Out.

It comes down to an honest assessment of your time tracking. If you are still billing 20 hours a week and spending the remaining 20 hours handling firm logistics, marketing, and managing staff, your compensation should be split 50/50 on your Profit & Loss statement. Half stays in direct labor (the cost of producing the legal work), and half moves to administrative overhead. As you scale and hire associates to take over the caseload, that ratio will naturally skew until 100% of your operational compensation sits in overhead, reflecting your true role as CEO.

Illustration ©iStockPhoto.com

Read more from Brooke Lively

“How Are Law Firm Owners Paid? Total Compensation vs. Salary”

“Funding Growth: Are You Starving Your Law Firm?”

“Understanding Law Firm Profits and What to Do With Them”

“Building a Law Firm That Pays You First”

share TWEET PIN IT share share
Brooke Lively Brooke Lively

Brooke Lively is the founder and CEO of two companies that address the needs of growing law firms. Cathcap provides fractional CFO services, and​ Scaling Law helps law firms implement the Entrepreneurial Operating System (EOS) to improve execution, accountability and long-term value.​ Brooke has spent more than 20 years working in and alongside the legal industry and has advised hundreds of law firms across the U.S. She is an international bestselling author and a Professional EOS Implementer who holds both an MBA and the Chartered Financial Analyst designation. Follow her on LinkedIn.

More Posts By This Author
MUST READ Articles for Law Firms Click to expand
envelope

Welcome to Attorney at Work!

       

Sign up for our free newsletter.

x

All fields are required. By signing up, you are opting in to Attorney at Work's free practice tips newsletter and occasional emails with news and offers. By using this service, you indicate that you agree to our Terms and Conditions and have read and understand our Privacy Policy.