share TWEET PIN IT share share 1
Set for Life Insurance Product Spotlight

Disability Insurance for Attorneys at Every Stage of Your Career

By Jamie Fleischner

Your most valuable asset is your ability to work. Do you have enough savings to sustain your lifestyle? Disability Insurance for attorneys can be complicated. Here are the basics.

disability insurance for attorneys

Your most valuable asset is your ability to work and produce an income. What would happen if you were too sick or injured to work? Do you have enough savings to sustain your lifestyle? Do you have a policy through your employer? If so, is it sufficient?

Disability Insurance for attorneys can be a complicated product and it is important to take into consideration your life stage when determining the most suitable policy for your needs. As you navigate throughout your career, it is important to reassess your disability insurance needs. It may be prudent to make modifications as your life circumstances change.

Here Are the Basic Parts of a Disability Policy

  • Six companies provide individual disability policies to attorneys: Guardian, Principal, Standard, MassMutual, Ameritas, and Ohio National.
  • Monthly benefit. The amount of monthly benefit you are eligible for depends on your income and if you have a group disability policy through your employer. It is important to calculate the amount you need for your household.
  • Individual policies are portable. If you leave your employer or move to a different state, you may take your policy with you.
  • Employer coverage. It is common for law firms to provide benefits to their employees. However, there are several drawbacks to consider. Most policies pay a percentage of your income such as 60% to a maximum such as $10k per month. If the employer is paying the premium, the benefits are taxable to you. Most group policies require you to be totally disabled to receive benefits.
  • Definition of disability. It is important that you have a policy that will cover you if you can’t work in your occupation regardless of income earned in another occupation. The top six companies listed all have a true own occupation definition of disability. Without this definition, the company is at the discretion to determine whether or not you are considered disabled.


Here are some common riders in disability policies.

  • A residual/partial disability policy will cover you if you aren’t totally disabled. The policy typically requires you to have a 15% or 20% loss of income to trigger a claim.
  • Increase options that allow you to increase benefits in the future without answering medical questions.
  • Consider noncancelable, guaranteed renewable language so that once you have a contract, they cannot modify or change your contract or increase your premiums.
  • A Cost of Living Adjustment Rider (COLA) will increase your benefits each year after you have been on claim for 1 year.

There are other riders that are typically not recommended such as a loan payment rider, CAT catastrophic rider, and a retirement rider.

Purchasing Disability Insurance Early in Your Career

Most people consider purchasing individual attorney disability insurance when they graduate from law school or are early in their careers. There are a lot of reasons to consider purchasing during this time of your career:

  • Law students may purchase up to $2,000 per month.
  • Attorneys in their first year out of law school may purchase up to $4,000 per month regardless of income.
  • No labs (blood and urine test) are necessary if purchasing less than $10,000 per month benefit.
  • When you purchase your policy at this stage you are locking in your rate at your current age and health which is likely the least expensive it will ever be. Once you have your policy, you may increase it in the future without answering any future medical questions.
  • Early in your career, you will want to stack your policy with most or all of the available riders since you are at the most vulnerable time in your career. You have the most potential income and likely the largest amount of debt you will ever have as well as the least amount of assets.
  • American Bar Association member discounts are available through Set for Life Insurance.

In Your 30s

  • During this stage of your career, the amount of available benefit will be based on your income and any group disability benefits in force.
  • If you purchase more than a $10,000 per month benefit, you will likely need to complete a paramedical exam (blood and urine test).
  • You will want to make sure you keep your policy up to date as your income changes and if you have a change in your employee benefits.
  • As you settle into your career, it is important to continue to review your policy when you have a life change such as purchasing a house, changing jobs, getting married, having kids, divorce, change in health, moving to a different state or receiving a significant change in income.

Middle Age

  • As you pay down your debt and accumulate assets, it is important to reassess your needs. Ask yourself the following questions to determine how to maintain your policy.
    • How much nontaxable benefit do I need to have to pay my bills?
    • Have you paid off debt and no longer have the burden of monthly payments?
    • Has your health changed?
    • Have you accumulated substantial assets elsewhere? If so, you may be able to remove the COLA rider, increase the elimination period and/or reduce the monthly benefit depending on your new criteria.


As you approach retirement, it is important to take a look at your financial situation and determine how much longer you need to keep your disability policy.

  • If you have had an adverse change in health, you may want to consider keeping the policy since you would likely not be able to go out and purchase the policy again. You may also need to file a claim in the coming years.
  • If you have had a change in health but have accumulated assets, you may want to consider modifying the policy by reducing the benefit, dropping the COLA rider, increasing the elimination period, and/or reducing the benefit period.
  • If you have accumulated enough assets where you can live off of your own funds, you may not need your policy anymore. First, assess what you have through your employer and make sure there would not be any penalties to tap your assets if you were to become disabled and needed to retrieve the money.
  • The policy will automatically expire at age 65. If you wish to continue the policy at that time, you need to prove you are working at least 32 hours a week and the benefit period will change to 24 months (depending on the company).
  • If you decide to drop your policy, you may want to consider a long-term care policy that would help protect your needs during your retirement years.

For more information about attorney disability insurance, to review your current disability insurance or to request a quote, contact:

Jamie Fleischner, CLU, ChFC, President, Set for Life Insurance
Cell 303-358-8021

setforlife logo for AAW

SPONSORED CONTENT. Product Spotlight showcases content provided by Attorney at Work sponsors and advertisers. This does not constitute an endorsement by Attorney at Work. See Terms and Conditions for more information.

Categories: Managing a Law Firm, Product Spotlight, You At Work
Originally published March 10, 2023
Last updated April 17, 2023
share TWEET PIN IT share share
Jamie K Jamie Fleischner

Jamie Fleischner is a nationally recognized independent insurance broker. Since 1993 she has specialized in helping thousands of high-income professionals with their disability insurance, term life insurance, and long-term care needs. She helps her clients by shopping around to find the most suitable policy at the best available rate.

More Posts By This Author
MUST READ Articles for Law Firms Click to expand

Welcome to Attorney at Work!

Sign up for our free newsletter.


All fields are required. By signing up, you are opting in to Attorney at Work's free practice tips newsletter and occasional emails with news and offers. By using this service, you indicate that you agree to our Terms and Conditions and have read and understand our Privacy Policy.